Silver ETF in India have become significantly more expensive than physical silver. They currently trade at a 10–15% premium due to a severe supply crunch and soaring investor demand. This situation has raised concerns among fund houses and analysts. Many recommend caution until premiums normalise.
In this blog, we break down why Silver ETFs are expensive, how to calculate premiums, and what investors should consider before buying.
Also read: Aditya Vision Share: Can Aditya Vision Ltd Become a Sector Leader in the Coming 5 Years?
Why Silver ETFs Are Expensive Now?
1. Supply Shock
There’s a severe shortage of LBMA-certified silver bars, the only type allowed for backing ETFs. Several mutual funds, including Tata Mutual Fund, SBI, Kotak, UTI, and Axis, have temporarily halted new inflows due to a lack of physical silver availability.
2. Investor Frenzy
Massive inflows into silver ETFs, which have been triple that of gold in 2025, have further tightened supply. This has pushed ETF Net Asset Values (NAVs) above the spot market price.
3. Global Short Squeeze
London lease rates for silver have surged over 30%, prompting global traders to hoard physical supply. This has created a feedback loop of higher premiums, affecting ETF prices in India.
Also read: Best Sugar Stocks in India – Why Sugar Stocks Are Rising?
Popular Silver ETFs in India
Some of the leading Silver ETFs available for investors are:
- Nippon India Silver ETF (SILVERBEES)
- ICICI Prudential Silver ETF
- HDFC Silver ETF
- SBI ETF Silver
- Kotak Silver ETF
- Tata Silver Exchange Traded Fund
These ETFs directly track silver prices but currently trade at premiums due to the supply-demand mismatch.
Comparing ETF iNAV with Real Silver Price
Investors can check if a Silver ETF is overpriced by comparing the intraday NAV (iNAV) with the spot price of silver.
Steps:
- Check iNAV from the fund’s website or NSE portal.
- Compare it with the MCX spot silver rate per kg (available on MCXIndia or India Bullion Association).
Rule of Thumb: If ETF/unit price ÷ iNAV > 1.10, you’re effectively paying 10%+ premium, and it may be wiser to wait for a correction.
Current Silver ETF Premium vs Spot (India) – October 15, 2025
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| MCX Spot Silver Price | ₹1,46,640 per kg | MCX |
| Nippon India Silver ETF Price (SILVERBEES) | ₹168.56 per unit | NSE |
| Nippon India Silver ETF NAV | ₹167.52 | Fund Website |
| ETF Premium Over NAV | ~0.6% intra-day premium | Calculated |
| Indian Silver Premium (Local vs Global) | 10–12% due to import parity | Industry |
| ETF Premium (over Spot Silver) | Average 10–19% industry-wide | Industry |
What this means: Indian investors face a total markup of 15–20% due to import and demand premiums plus ETF trading premiums. Several funds have suspended fresh inflows to protect investors.
How to Calculate Silver ETF NAV vs Physical Silver Price
Understanding Silver ETF premiums is crucial before investing. Each unit usually represents 1 gram of silver, adjusted for fund costs and taxes.
Source: Website
Step 1: Identify Physical Silver Benchmark
Use the spot price from MCX or India Bullion and Jewellers Association (IBJA).
Example (Oct 15, 2025): ₹1,46,640/kg = ₹146.64/gram.
Step 2: Get Latest ETF NAV
Example: Nippon India Silver ETF NAV = ₹167.52.
Step 3: Compare ETF NAV and Market Price
Premium (%) = ((ETF Market Price − Spot Silver Price) ÷ Spot Silver Price) × 100
NAV Premium (%) = ((ETF Market Price − NAV) ÷ NAV) × 100
Example:
ETF Market Price = ₹168.56
Spot Silver = ₹146.64
Premium = ((168.56 − 146.64) ÷ 146.64) × 100 ≈ 14.9%
Step 4: Adjust for Import Parity
Indian ETFs use LBMA price + customs duties + GST (~10–12%). This adjustment makes the ETF NAV closer to physical parity.
Key Takeaway: ETF prices mirror domestic silver prices but may deviate temporarily due to tracking errors, storage costs, or fund expenses. Checking iNAV provides the fairest real-time comparison.
Risks of Buying Silver ETFs During a Supply Squeeze
Investing in Silver ETFs at this stage carries significant risks:
- Mark-to-Market Losses: Premiums may compress as supply normalises, causing immediate losses.
- Tracking Error & Price Dislocation: ETF prices can overshoot actual silver due to halted unit creation.
- Reduced Liquidity: Fund suspensions limit new investments, making exits harder.
- Overpaying for Short-Term Exposure: Investors buying now may face short-term downside if the rally cools.
- Structural Supply Deficits: Global silver production rarely responds fast enough to sudden investment demand, prolonging premiums.
Source: The Economic Times
Investor Takeaway: Wait for premiums to normalise before making large entries. Avoid chasing rallies or lump-sum buying during a supply squeeze.
When to Consider Buying Silver ETF?
Experts suggest the next buying window may open when:
- Premiums fall below 3–4%
- Silver-to-gold ratio rises above 80, signalling silver undervaluation relative to gold
- Speculative inflows cool post-festive season, likely early 2026
Portfolio Allocation Example (₹10 lakh portfolio for 2025–26):
| Asset | Allocation | Amount (₹) | Investment Route |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gold ETFs | 10% | 1,00,000 | Wealth preservation & inflation hedge |
| Silver ETFs (gradual) | 15% | 1,50,000 | SIP after premium correction |
| Equity Mutual Funds | 65% | 6,50,000 | Long-term growth |
| Debt Instruments | 10% | 1,00,000 | Stability & liquidity |
Holding Period: Invest in silver for 3–5 years minimum, as structural demand from EVs, solar panels, and 5G continues to grow. Long-term targets predict silver reaching ₹2,45,000/kg by 2026–27.
Should You Buy Silver ETF Now?
Given current premiums, Silver ETFs are expensive and risky for short-term investors. While silver remains a good long-term asset, patience is key. Waiting for a premium correction and buying gradually through SIPs is the safer strategy.
Remember: Silver ETFs are a tactical growth play. They are volatile, moving roughly 1.7x faster than gold, both on upside and downside.
Final Thoughts
Silver ETFs offer convenient exposure to the precious metal, but extreme supply shortages and high premiums in India make immediate buying risky. Investors should focus on:
- Monitoring iNAV and spot silver prices
- Waiting for premium normalisation
- Using staggered investments rather than lump-sum purchases
By following these strategies, you can minimise short-term risks while benefiting from silver’s long-term growth potential.
That’s all for today’s post. Hope you get some valuable insights from here.
Happy reading!
Disclaimer
The blog is meant for informational purposes and serves the general analysis of the stocks. The contents provided here are based on careful research and analysis utilizing the fundamental and technical indicators over a while. The post does not have any direct recommendations about investing or trading in the securities market. Thorough research and careful consideration are necessary for individuals to fulfill their responsibility in making financial decisions. Seeking professional advice before making any financial decisions is always advisable.